Is Buying Cheaper Than Renting

Colin Delaney March 28, 2012

Buy vs. Rent in Costa Mesa real estate

Perhaps you’ve seen the upswing in rents late if you rent in Costa Mesa, or perhaps you saw the recent article on CNN’s webpage that buying may now be cheaper than renting a home. And I know this won’t concern lots of you because you will be winning that lottery this week, anyway right?🙂
 

Is Buying Cheaper Than Renting

Let’s look at the basics – rents have gone way up. If you currently rent a home in Costa Mesa real estate for under $3,000 a month, consider yourself lucky. Rents around Orange County are way, way up. Costa Mesa has always been less expensive, but it is getting considerably more pricey as the year goes on. Demand for rentals is steep with so many people coming out of ownership for reasons of short sales, foreclosures, or not being able to qualify to buy themselves. The rental market will continue like this for the next twelve months without a doubt.
 
 

Basic Economics

As the demand for rentals increases, and lack of rental inventory continues, buying looks like a better option. Combine that fact with fact that interest rates remain low and home prices are down, and you have the equation for the right time to buy.
 

True Home Value

Let’s compare what it would cost to rent the average Costa Mesa real estate home vs. owning it every month.
 
I’m going to use the same $3,000 monthly value as a rental amount, and I will compare that to an average 4-bedroom home in Costa Mesa real estate.
 
  Renting     Owning
Monthly Rent Renting$3,000 VS. Monthly Mortgage Owning$2,308
Utilities RentingSame   PMI Owning$201
     Renting   Taxes Owning$468
     Renting   Utilities OwningSame
Total Cost Renting$3,000   Total Cost Owning$2,972
 
Now, I have taken some assumptions out of the equation to answer the question “Is Buying Cheaper Than Renting”. There will be repairs that you will have to pay for on the owning side of the equation, there is always home maintenance that you have to take care of. Things break, that is just the reality. Also, you have to put $16,500 down (3.5%) to buy that home with an FHA loan. And those come with PMI insurance. Buying with 20% removes great cost from this side.
 
Try one of our calculators to figure what works best for you
 
But the biggest takeaway now is that if you own a home all of your mortgage and taxes all help to reduce your income taxes. And trust me, that is a significant number the first 10 years of a new mortgage. On this loan example above you could expect all of the interest as a write down off of your taxable income. That’s significant.
 

Pendulum Swing

No, it won’t stay like this forever in Costa Mesa real estate. The one item pushing our area into a buyer’s advantage is the significantly reduced interest rates. Rates as of this writing are just a hair over 4%. Once they get over 6% you can see the pendulum swing the other way. Here’s a good rent vs. buy calculator if you want to do the math for yourself.
 
Interested in buying? Colin Delaney can help and can be reached at (714) 743-9882 or E-mail me here to reach me. Here are some 4 bedrooms for sale in Costa Mesa where it would be cheaper to buy, and yes it Is Buying Cheaper Than Renting.

Recent Blog Posts

Avoid Mistakes-Top 5 Tips To Winning Offers in a Seller’s Market

Colin Delaney  |  September 3, 2025

Here’s a winning strategy with tips to avoid common buyer mistakes.

Just Sold: Cardinal – What’s the Market Really Like?

Colin Delaney  |  May 29, 2024

Sharing the nuts and bolts of this sale helps illustrate what is going on right now.

Just Sold – 2717 Cardinal Drive

Colin Delaney  |  May 6, 2024

Highest price paid for this model of approx 1814 Square feet.

Recent Mesa Verde Neighborhood Sales 2024

Colin Delaney  |  May 5, 2024

Here are the recent Mesa Verde neighborhood sales for 2024 through the end of April.

New Listing Video – 2717 Cardinal Drive

Colin Delaney  |  March 13, 2024

So excited to share our new short film for our listing at 2717 Cardinal Drive!

New Listing! 2717 Cardinal Drive, Costa Mesa CA 92626

Colin Delaney  |  March 10, 2024

This home has lovingly been cared for and has been in the same family for more than 40 years.

2024 Costa Mesa Real Estate Predictions

Colin Delaney  |  January 2, 2024

It’s the one where I am forecasting everything that is about to happen in Costa Mesa real estate.

Spring 2023 | Mesa Verde Market Report

Colin Delaney  |  April 10, 2023

We typically see listings start to trickle on the market in late February, with an increase in March.

Mesa Verde Home Inventory at 5 (!)

Colin Delaney  |  January 14, 2023

Mesa Verde Home Inventory for active listings is currently at 5 active listings.

Work With Colin

Colin’s commitment to getting sellers top dollar and securing the best deals for buyers is backed by a proven track record and extensive local knowledge.